Surprise! Andrew Rannells & Original ‘Book of Mormon’ Cast Reuniting Live at the 79th Tony Awards — How to Watch

Andrew Rannells is turning 2026 into a banner year of exits, reunions and fresh starts. The two-time Tony nominee has confirmed he will step away from the title role in the new Elton John–Jake Shears musical Tammy Faye, with Tony winner Christian Borle set to take over on Broadway. While fans digest that surprise shake-up, Rannells is already teasing what comes next. First up is a highly anticipated reunion: the original cast of The Book of Mormon will open the 79th Annual Tony Awards on 7 June. Rannells will reprise his breakout turn as Elder Price alongside Josh Gad and the rest of the 2011 company in a one-night-only performance that producers promise will be “as irreverent as ever”. Industry insiders say the appearance could boost ticket sales for the long-running hit—still a top tourist draw—while reminding TV audiences of Rannells’ comic chops. Those chops are also headed to streaming. Deadline reports that Rannells and real-life “Broadway bestie” Gad are developing an as-yet-untitled workplace comedy for Hulu, marking their first screen project together since Mormon debuted 15 years ago. Sources close to the production say a pilot script is nearly finished, with filming eyed for early 2027. Rannells has been fueling the hype on social media. “This Monday the 16th Trey, Matt, Bobby and I will take over @colbertlateshow!” the actor wrote in a March Instagram post, hinting at a late-night mini-reunion with Mormon creators Parker, Stone and Lopez. The cryptic tease sent fans scrambling for tickets to the taping and sparked speculation about a future concert tour or cast album re-release. Why the sudden flurry of activity? Observers point to a perfect convergence: the Tony Awards’ milestone year, Tammy Faye’s demanding schedule and Hulu’s appetite for Broadway-branded content. “Andrew wants to strike while the iron is hottest,” notes one veteran talent manager. Exiting Tammy Faye frees him for award-season press, while the Hulu deal guarantees a post-Tonys spotlight. For theatre lovers, the bigger question is whether Rannells might circle back to Broadway after the Hulu shoot wraps. Producers of both Spamalot and Something Rotten! have quietly courted the Omaha native in recent months, according to multiple casting sources. Rannells’ reps declined comment, but the actor has said he’s “always looking for the next fun challenge”—language that keeps the rumor mill spinning. With a Tony telecast performance, a high-profile casting shake-up and a new TV series all landing within months, Andrew Rannells is positioning himself at the center of multiple conversations in entertainment this summer. For fans—and for search engines—expect his name to stay top of mind long after the Tonys confetti settles.